Haunted Asylum causes controversy over mockery of mentally ill
Fundraising event by drama club and student life draws 400.
By Sami Parman
Issue date: 11/2/07 Section: News
Originally published: 11/1/07 at 12:45 PM CSTLast update: 11/6/07 at 12:54 PM CST
| |
| |
| |
|
The club presented the Haunted Asylum, an event co-sponsored by the office of student life Oct. 26-28 in Loftin Student Center. More than 400 people walked through the Halloween attraction that consisted of scary scenes, such as a patient receiving an electric shock treatment.
The event raised more than $500 for the club's trip to London in April.
When a campuswide e-mail was sent advertising the event, Professor James P. "Buzz" McBride voiced his concerns to theater and speech communication Chair Jeff Hunt about the image the haunted asylum might portray.
"Mr. McBride was concerned the asylum was going to make fun of the mentally ill and preserve the negative stigma associated with the mentally ill," Hunt said Oct 29.
McBride has been involved in a mental health support group for 10 years at First Baptist Universal City. The group mainly sees parents with children diagnosed with bipolar disorder and occasionally people diagnosed with schizophrenia, he said.
McBride suggested the department change the event to the haunted house, but it had already been advertised as the Haunted Asylum, and plans moved forward as scheduled.
"He was very apologetic when I pointed out that it could add to the stigmas for the mentally ill," McBride said about his conversation with Hunt. "You couldn't ask for a better demeanor than he expressed."
McBride did not go to the asylum, but he said he saw photos of the event.
"They weren't out of the ordinary for Halloween," he said, "but that wasn't the point."
Hunt met with the club's adviser, theater Instructor Paula Rodriguez, explaining McBride's concerns and a possible solution to the problem.
"We told the students not to portray a certain disease. They were acting more like criminals," Hunt said.
"They were mostly acting like characters from movies," Rodriguez said, "'Dawn of the Dead,' Norman Bates from 'Psycho' and a lot of cannibals and zombies walking around."
The actors were told by Lori Roman, club president and theater sophomore, to research specific diseases and portray one or two diseases to the best of their abilities.
"We wanted to do an asylum because we could research better and perform to our full extent," Roman said Oct 26.
"Technically, we are mocking insane people," she said, "but we're doing this for fun. It's Halloween."
One of the first patrons to walk through was a Ripley's Haunted Adventure director, Hunt said.
"It is not your typical haunted house," Hunt said the director told him.
Hunt agrees with McBride that the event should have been titled haunted house.
The group and student life plan to continue hosting a haunted house every year, but the themes will differ from year to year, Hunt said.
2008 Woodie Awards




This is an open forum for the readers of TheRanger.org. Abusive, inflammatory, slanderous, obscene and libelous language will not be tolerated. Please be considerate of other readers when posting comments. This is not the place for personal attacks. The staff of The Ranger.org reserves the right to deny publication of any posts. The comments posted here do not reflect the opinions of The Ranger staff, San Antonio College or the Alamo Community College District.
Viewing Comments 1 - 4 of 5
Alison Vasquez
posted 11/02/07 @ 3:01 PM CST
I am amazed that there are people at a college who do not accept art for art sake.
First, I would like to commend the Drama Club as offering a safe place for students to go for fun. (Continued…)
Melanie
posted 11/06/07 @ 11:33 AM CST
Yeah, okay...I agree artistic expression should be protected, but...what about making choices with civic responsibility? Not political correctness or religious obeyance (sp?) - bowing down to religion. (Continued…)
Celeste
posted 11/08/07 @ 7:09 AM CST
There will never be a topic of any sort that can please everyone, that is a basic fact. While many people may disagree with me, I feel political correctness has become completely farcical. (Continued…)
Victorhugo
posted 2/14/08 @ 10:35 AM CST
As a participant of the asylum I did understand that this subject would be rocky ground, but if any of the reporters want to write quotes that they received from members, it should be written in the report as the quote was said not how the reporter wants to accept it. (Continued…)
Post a Comment